Regional economic growth to suffer from student visa reforms

Latest figures of 0.2 percent GDP growth show the UK's climb out of recession to be uncertain and sluggish. It seems that the Home Office could not have predicted worse timing for the release of a new Home Affairs Committee damning report on the consequences of the changes to student visas.

It's official: these changes are set to cost the economy £3.4 billion; a disconcerting revelation for the embattled George Osborne who also has to monitor the Euro-crisis and the fiscal turmoil in Greece.

The over-arching message from Select Comittee report is that the government needs to seriously consider the growing challenges of the UK’s economy and the impact of restricting foreign students on income generated by research and innovation in higher education -  issues which it thinks have not yet been properly considered.

International students' contribution to the economy

The UK’s economy is bolstered by the funding stream of overseas students, an industry ‘worth up to £40 billion’ and provides a direct contribution of ‘up to £12.5 billion’ annually to revenue. There is no denying that the government faces some considerable challenges in reforming the current immigration system and trying to balance an economy in freefall. But major restrictions on foreign student visas announced earlier this year have created real panic across the education sector about loss of income. This week's report by the Select Committee suggests that economic contributions by foreign students will be cut drastically, producing widespread reductions in net income across the Treasury’s coffers.

These concerns are not new, but has the government taken them seriously yet? Back in March at a meeting of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Migration (APPG) a group of MPs and experts warned that reforms of such magnitude will have a negative impact on Higher Education institutions and on wider economic growth. Following the meeting the chair of the APPG Jack Dromey MP, asked the Home Secretary whether the economic impacts of restricting international students would be considered – and received the response that the government had no intention of doing so.

It seems the dismissal of these concerns has now come back to haunt the government. In particular, the regional economic impacts of restrictions on international students look to be significant and could endanger government efforts to rebalance regional economies.

The effect of student visa reforms on regional economies

Unlike other core British industries such as manufacturing, IT and financial services, which tend to concentrate economic growth within particular regions, income from international students contributes to all the regions and devolved countries of the UK. Many FE and HE institutions provide wider employment opportunities, generate income for local industries and the private housing sector, and offer a wider boost to local economic dynamism within their region. Education providers in the UK argue that they are able to consolidate their role as hubs of innovation and economic regeneration by drawing upon international talent and revenue.

Contribution of International revenu to regional economiesAs such, regional economies are likely to be hit the hardest by restrictions on international students which are viewed as short-sighted and counter-productive. The Scottish Home Affairs Committee sees these changes as potentially deterring "genuine, high-calibre" students from applying to study in Scotland.

The failure to ask the government’s own immigration guru, the Migration Advisory Committee, to assess what damage will be dealt to the economy as a result of curbing overseas students, displays a disregard of what immigration experts have to say on the issue.

If it had done so, these issues and potential solutions could have been provided earlier in a cost-effective way, giving the government political ownership on the matter and better planning for impacts on national and regional economic growth. Sadly, however, this looks to have been a missed opportunity.

This article was first published on the Left Foot Forward blog. If you would like to find out more about the work of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Migration visit their website or get in touch with Awale Olad.

Other users went on to read:


Here is an interesting article in the Guardian on the topic.

Colleges to challenge student visa clampdown

Association of UK Private Schools and Colleges will ask high court to review Theresa May's plan to fix 'broken' system

A note on commenting

Due to recent increased commenting activity we have taken the decision to disable commenting on old blogs. As we are a small office it is simply impossible to fight spam and keep removing comments that don’t comply with our house rules on what is now an archive of over 800 pieces.

We have also decided to take a more proactive role in enforcing our blog house rules on the blogs where comments are open. The rules are there for a good reason and we want to make sure we are consistent and apply them across the board. 

This is not in any shape or form meant to stifle debate, but to make sure that it remains civil and on topic.

Thanks and best regards,

--MRN Team

MRN blogging and comments – Policy and House Rules

Your comments

1. Please be civil– we will remove anything that:

  • Is considered likely to provoke, attack or offend others
  • Is racist, sexist, homophobic, sexually explicit, abusive or otherwise objectionable
  • Contains swear words or other language likely to offend
  • Breaks the law, condones or encourage unlawful activity or which could endanger the safety or well-being of others
  • Impersonates someone else
  • advertises products or services

2. Comments that could damage the reputation of a person or organisation, that risk prejudicing on-going or forthcoming court proceedings or that could place MRN in contravention of its legal and/or regulatory obligations will be removed.

3. Please make comments relevant to the subject of the article. We may remove comments that we consider to be spam or which are unrelated to the article content against which they are posted.

4. Please keep the number of comments you make on a topic reasonable. Too many posts from an individual or small group can discourage other readers from joining the conversation.

5. In exceptional cases we may get a high volume of similar comments on a post. In these cases we may close comments for that post, adding a note letting you know that further comments will not be published.

6. By submitting comments to this site, you warrant that such comments are not defamatory nor infringe any law. You agree to indemnify MRN against all legal fees, damages and other expenses that may be incurred by MRN as a result of your breach of the above warranty.